Every strategy and guide published by North Shore is backed by the board-certified expertise of our Co-Founders. With decades of combined experience in holistic admissions, Amy and Debbie ensure our guidance is objective, unbiased, and focused exclusively on your student's best fit.
Does demonstrated interest matter? Families argue about this constantly, and the argument is strange, because it is one of the only questions in admissions that colleges answer directly, in writing, in a public document. Most families have never been told where the answer sits, so the household defaults to superstition: visit every campus just in case, open every email just in case, sign every card at every fair just in case.
The answer, school by school, is in Section C7 of each college's Common Data Set, a standardized disclosure nearly every college publishes annually. C7 lists the factors the college uses in admission decisions and rates each one Very Important, Important, Considered, or Not Considered. One row in that table reads "Level of applicant's interest." That row is the college stating, on the record, whether tracking your student's engagement plays any role in how applications are evaluated. Finding it takes about two minutes per school. What C7 cannot tell you is what happens between a human reader and a file, and that second layer is where this post ends up.
Finding the answer takes two minutes. Your student searches the school's name plus "Common Data Set," opens the most recent year's file, and scrolls to the C7 table. The interest row states the school's answer.
Read it literally. Not Considered means the college is telling you that engagement tracking plays no formal role in how files are scored. Considered, Important, or Very Important means the school does factor engagement into its evaluation, and the effort your student spends there is strategy rather than superstition.
Three insider notes on reading the table. First, the ratings move. A school can mark interest Not Considered one cycle and Considered the next, because enrollment pressures change. Rerun the check against the current year's file rather than trusting a list from any blog post, including this one. Second, the folk wisdom is wrong often enough to matter. The usual shorthand says big public universities never track interest, but the University of Michigan's own Common Data Set lists level of applicant's interest as Considered. We have watched industry blogs assert the opposite in the same month Michigan's filing said otherwise. The document beats everyone's memory, including professionals'. Third, the broad lean is still real: interest tends to matter most at private colleges and mid-sized universities where the admissions office is genuinely uncertain which admits will enroll. From what admissions officers we know describe, that is what the tracking is for. It is not a loyalty reward. It is enrollment forecasting, and your student's contact history is one of the inputs.
The tracking is not a folder of sticky notes. Most admissions offices run on a CRM platform, and the dominant one in college admissions is Slate, built by Technolutions, with competitors filling the same role elsewhere. Every applicant has a record in that system, and the record holds more than the application. Depending on how the school configures it, logged touchpoints can include information session registrations, campus visit check-ins, sign-ins from the rep's visit to your student's high school, college fair card scans, optional interview bookings, portal logins, and engagement with the school's emails.
The September version of this is concrete: when the rep visits the cafeteria this fall and your student signs the card, that card is a CRM entry. At a school whose C7 row says interest is considered, the entry becomes part of the file's context. At a Not Considered school, it is a mailing list signup. Same card, two different machines behind it, and C7 told you which one in advance.
What the contact record is not is a volume contest. An inbox campaign does not read as four times the interest, and admissions offices can see the difference between engagement and performance. The touchpoints that count tend to be the ones where the student actually showed up and actually decided something.
Now the layer C7 cannot capture. At every college, including the ones whose C7 row reads Not Considered, applications are read and decisions are made by people. Holistic review means a human being sits with your student's file, and human beings form impressions, remember names, and develop genuine connections with applicants they have come to know across a cycle: through a meaningful question after a high school visit, a thoughtful piece of written communication, a real conversation at a regional event.
An admissions officer at Boston College once told us that when they get to know an applicant through interactions like these over the course of a cycle, they will sometimes put a Post-it note with that student's name on their desk or monitor, a reminder to read that file extra closely when it comes up, and, if the student is qualified, to pull for them in the process or in committee over an equally qualified applicant they have never heard from. No C7 row captures that. It is not a tracked metric. It is a person remembering a person.
Be careful what conclusion you draw. This is not license for a contact campaign; a generic email to an admissions inbox creates no connection, and twenty of them create a negative one. What the Post-it note story actually says is that the official rating governs the tracking system, not the human beings, and that the small number of genuine interactions your student has are worth doing well everywhere, not only at the schools that score them.
What Your Student Should Do
Three moves, in order.
Run the C7 check on the working list. One evening. For every school, your student pulls the current Common Data Set and records the interest rating next to the school's name.
Reallocate the effort by what the check found. Engagement hours flow first to the schools that consider interest: the rep visit at their high school, the regional session, the optional interview where offered. For the Not Considered schools, the same hours move to what those schools do weigh, most often the supplements, while the handful of natural human touchpoints still get done well.
Keep visiting for the right reason. A campus visit to a Not Considered school is not wasted; it is how your student finds out whether they can picture four years there. It just is not a scored event, and knowing the difference is the point of the check.
One calendar wrinkle: colleges publish the new CDS at different points in the year, so in August some schools' most recent file is a cycle old. It is still the best public evidence available, and rerunning the check when new files post is a ten-minute update.
You don't have to navigate the complexities of college admissions alone. Whether you are aiming for the Ivy League, a top-tier public university, or a highly selective major, our expert counselors are here to help you craft a personal brand that stands out.
